A side of passable mashed potatoes arrived in a small pot without a serving utensil. Sorry. Amenities: Wheelchair accessible. The Highlawn is the gem of Essex County and New Jersey, a landmark venue where exceptional food and service create memories to last a lifetime. Our tables are positioned at a minimum of six feet apart and are thoroughly disinfected after each seating. In December 1985, Harry and Wade Knowles traveled throughout northern Italy seeking design elements and color schemes to inform The Highlawns dcor. Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday | 5:00 pm 10:00 pm Bar closes one hour later, Friday Saturday | 5:00 pm 11:00 pmBar closes at 12:00 am or later. We had to walk in through a toxic cloud provided by smokers, our table wasnt ready, and there was a very loud party happening upstairs. American, Steakhouse, Italian Hours of operation Tue-Sun 5:00 pm-10:00 pm Brunch Sun 11:00 am-3:00 pm Lunch Tue-Fri 11:30 am-3:00 pm Phone number (973) 731-3463 Website http://www.highlawn.com/ Dress code Business Casual Catering Gentleman at the next table sported a tee shirt and sneakers. Many people come to order good hot fudge sundae, fudge and chocolate mousse. Event though it was hot, you are just going from one air conditioned place to another. The food and the service were excellent, and the surroundings are beautiful you can see the NY Skyline. Incredible 6 course meal great service and live entertainment! I believe you can come dressed casually. Delicious wine, bourbon or white wine are the best drinks of this bar. If you want to be allowed to wear shorts, go to a less upscale restaurant. An outstanding job. Duck with polenta was very warm and enjoyable. The Reservation building had deteriorated to the point of becoming a safety hazard, and it was decided that the entire building should be demolished. The dining room is beautiful and the night that I was there, the view was spectacular. Which is EXACTLY what happened to me. All employees must regularly undergo COVID-19 testing and will have their temperatures taken each day. The Highland also has a magnificent view of the city which my wife loved. The first floor was designed without windows as an open-air room, earning it the nickname The Casino, which refers to an Italian-style country dwelling or summer home. The event space hosts 15-65 guests and is the ideal setting for any gathering. View great, food barely edible, service beyond terrible. If you want to be allowed to wear shorts, go to a less upscale restaurant. then any fast food you can get anywhere, baffles the mind!! Who wears shorts to a nice restaurant and thinks that is okay? Of which there are plenty. Shorts at the Highlawn is ridiculous. I do enjoy the minor detail that these two were kicked out of HP and ended up eating at Ricalton's for some reason. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. The view is phenomenal. More elaborate dishes were less successful. The "Sicilian" crudo appy was a pastiche of olives, citrus sections, fish and presumably Sicilian olive oil. Highlawn Pavilion American Restaurant, Event Space, and New American Restaurant $$$ $ West Orange Save Share Tips 17 Photos 147 Menu 8.7/ 10 109 ratings Menu Dessert Menu 4 $39 Three-Course Prix Fixe Piano Room Menu 3 Dinner Menu 3Bar Menu 5 Wine List 3 Lunch Menu 4 Dessert Menu Desserts Pineapple Cre?meux Tart 9.50 Great food, SUPERB service (thank you PAT! Since we moved to the Jersey Shore and many friends passed, we had not been there. emmie Aug 21, 2014 at 4:27pm Edited Highlawn is air conditioned , your car probably is too,no need to wear shorts to a classy place like the Highlawn. My husband wears shorts with a button-down oxford to Huntley Taverne and we have a wonderful meal and are treated like royalty. The elegantly arched dining room windows afford a spectacular panorama of New York City's twinkling lights and distant landings and takeoffs at Newark Liberty International Airport. You can't throw on a pair of nice trousers, a tasteful shirt and dress shoes for dinner? Map. Waited 45 years to go to this restaurant. This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. If you don't agree with the dress code, don't patronize the restaurant. The Highlawn provides elegant New American dining with sweeping views of New York City. They even were skimpy with the bread too! The view was fascinating , so ask for a window table. Service: far below what one expects at these prices. Restaurant is classy, elegant, sophisticated. Well, first I try to get out of going but then I call and ask what the dress code is. 1 Crest Dr, West Orange, NJ 07052 973.731.3463. Essex County Eagle Rock September 11th Memorial. The food was fine, nothing special. Women should wear something nice, since you will still be in an upscale restaurant and many people will go the bar before dining. What's Up With The 1980's Dress Code At Highlawn P. They even were skimpy with the bread too!More, Reserved for dinner here because of a very nice buffet reception for business a couple of weeks ago. And it was a weeknight in mid-August at an empty bar. Staff was polite but inexperienced. Highlawn Pavilion, West Orange: See 407 unbiased reviews of Highlawn Pavilion, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 96 restaurants in West Orange. I think what an earlier poster says about the generational gap is right on the money. She was nice, though. From business lunches to anniversaries, our team is ready to help you plan the perfect event. No real COVID precautions: most but not all staff masked; no diners masked; no social distancing (though tables aren't crowded); no "are you vaccinated"? What is the phone number of Highlawn Pavilion? To communicate or ask something with the place, the Phone number is (973) 731-3463. The revamped Highlawn from the original Highlawn Pavillion was really great. Highlawn Pavilion is a turn-of-the-century Florentine-style pavilion that has been beautifully restored to European grandeur with breathtaking views of Manhattan. From the expansive vantage point, he was able to anticipate the movement of British troops by the location of their campfires in the countryside below. This sample pack comes complete with all the Royalty-Free elements you need to create your own arrangements and is perfectly suited to Hip-Hop, RnB, Funk/Soul productions. I think the bartender probably didn't want to say anything and he should have if that is the policy. FAIL !!! Shorts are still shorts, even if they are "dress" shorts. "Upscale restaurant with the best view of NYC ." (2 Tips) "views of Manhattan skyline but somehow the look and feel" (2 Tips) "Lunch on the patio with views of NYC skyline" (3 Tips) more, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options. No vegetables or other accompaniments for $42. After 35 year, Highlawn Pavilion changes owners with a reopening on the horizon, The Highlawn in West Orange hires key personal ahead of relaunch, ROI Influencers: Food & Beverage 2021 (A to F). Under this circumstance, The Highlawn might consider establishing a dress code for their hostess, who is the first employee diners likely see. Definitely a revisit. A great place for a date or celebration. Our server was very nice. The host knew it was a special place to us yet when I asked would not sit us next to the window because another couple decided to have a drink at the bar and he was holding this table for them. Make sure to call the manager "Nick" for a gret table, clams. Plenty of restaurants have dress codes. OMG I feel your pain! First waiter returned briefly, seemed surprised that we'd ordered, and then disappeared for the evening. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews. The Grill is modern steakhouse dining at its finest, with top quality meats, New American entrees, impeccable service and spectacular views. In the NY Netropolitan area you go out on a date night with your honey who is well dressed in a skirt and heels and you are wearing shorts. FAIL !!! It's a shame that there isn't a Daivd Burke Restaurant close by. I don't have a strong opinion other than recommending some white linen pants and no socks. More elaborate dishes were less successful. I happen to think Highlawn is a bit full of themselves but they do have a right to have a dress code. Men don't need a tie, but you should wear nice pants and a polo or dress shirt. I would never wear shorts to an expensive restaurant. Seated at a table for four the other two place settings remained throughout the meal, as if there were spectral guests at the table. She knows better. I would never wear shorts to an expensive restaurant. @conandrob240, I think he is saying that he was wearing dress shorts with a button down business shirt. Some lesser wines by the glass at about $15; OK, but not in keeping with the "gourmet" pretensions. There isn't a nice way to say this (or there is but I'm too tired to come up with it): grow up! The spring, the Highlawn underwent extensive renovations, and reopened to a waiting public in September. Eh. Hotels near Thomas Edison National Historical Park, Hotels near Paddle Boating and Picnic Pavilion, Hotels near Essex County Eagle Rock September 11th Memorial, Hotels near Essex County Regatta Playground, Hotels near Jean-Jacque's Chicken & Waffles Tour, Hotels near Nia Fellowship Baptist Church, Hotels near Ahawas Achim B'nai Jacob & David. All listings are informational only. At this price point, the ambiance, service and food should be much better.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. The chef will surprise and delight you, no matter how gastro-sophisticated you might be. He made excellent suggestions for appetizers and entrees. Simple. This is a great date/anniversary/special occasion place. I would also be annoyed if I worked hard preparing a good meal and guests showed up in shorts. I had a very similar thing happen to me! Shorts are still shorts, even if they are "dress" shorts. We have implemented a heightened cleaning and sanitizing regimen, including continual disinfecting of our restrooms. 8.7/ 10. They don't want your money, so don't give it to them. Looks like the designer had no ideas. Atmosphere was festive and energetic without being crazy and chaotic. You can wear a nice shirt with them but they are still shorts. Would you be able to host a sweet 16 and if so what are the average prices. HOURS OF OPERATIONTuesday - Friday: 11:30AM - 3PM (Lunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner)Saturday 5PM- 10PM (Dinner & Bar)Sunday: 11:00AM -3PM (Brunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner). 1 Crest Dr, West Orange, NJ 07052 973.731.3463. PRICE RANGE $25 - $100 Special Diets Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options Meals 109. ratings. The salmon was perfectly prepared and the piccata was excellent. Appreciated the smaller cuts for less-hearty appetites. I would recommend this place. They should have spoken before seating but They have a dress code posted on the website. View Our Menus. The venue, located atop Essex County Eagle Rock Reservation, has begun taking reservations for high-end celebrations, too. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Food was brought to the table by a young bussboy who said, cordially enough, "You guys enjoy" with each course. The Highlawn is one of the tri-state areas most magical venues for weddings, anniversaries, bar and bat mitzvahs, birthdays, corporate events and celebrations of any kind. Valet parking (concession): the stub had a pre-printed "suggested tip." 355 N State Rt 17, Paramus, NJ, 07652 . My bronzino consisted of two little strips of fish with some sauce. Desserts were disappointing. OMG I feel your pain! Detailed Reviews: Reviews order informed by descriptiveness of user-identified themes such as cleanliness, atmosphere, general tips and location information. Men don't need a tie, but you should wear nice pants and a polo or dress shirt. Interestingly, in much warmer climates than much of America, (southern Europe, Middle East, etc.) Just ask. Good valet parking and handicapped accessible. Renovations and additions to the historic Highlawn Pavilion include a new upper-level terrace addition connected to a 2 nd floor event space, the design of an event building sharing resources of the main structure for private events and extensive site and exterior upgrades enlarging the seating and usable area for guests and the public. That sort of thing is OK at the local diner for breakfest, but not here. Single use menus will be provided upon request. (That said, I DON'T think it's unreasonable to wear shorts to a place like that if you're going to be sitting at and eating at the bar. The horror!!! The Highlawn welcomes groups of all sizes for any occasion. I'm sorry, but perhaps you missed the point. Amazing viewMore, For many years the Highlawn Pavilion was a special occasion venue for us and friends. Get quick answers from Highlawn Pavilion staff and past visitors. Santa was great! Valet parking (concession): the stub had a pre-printed "suggested tip." My husband, who works as a creative and never wears a suit except at weddings refuses to go to restaurants that have dress codes. Drinks good but a class of wine seems pricey. More about Highlawn Pavilion . Promote your business here - Businesses get highlighted throughout the site and you can add a deal. But they have every right to set a dress code. I had the chicken parm which was the BEST I've ever had. When we arrive Mrs. M notifies the host that we have already made reservations and he kindly points us in the direction of our table. I will definitely go there again. Exactly. I'm sorry, but perhaps you missed the point. I love the atmosphere and the scenery is beautiful. Given the price point here, one wonders Perhaps they knew something, or someone - they received far better service than we. My 4-star review represents disappointment with the noise and mayhem at this normally elegant restaurant, plus a degree of unhappiness with the limited menu. It's not the dress code itself it's the way he was treated. I mean, it is BIZARRE. I'm working on him making an exception for my birthday because I want to go to Le Bernadin, but so far no success! What are they thinking? I don't have a strong opinion other than recommending some white linen pants and no socks. Loved everything & cant wait to return to enjoy the outside patio! Desserts were disappointing. The overlook upon which The Highlawn sits began as a natural trap dike formation, a glacially cut area where the Palisades Cliffs move inland to form a trap rock cliff above the Atlantic coastal plain. And if you were really that hot, wear a linen pant. Highlawn Pavilion, West Orange: See 405 unbiased reviews of Highlawn Pavilion, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 101 restaurants in West Orange. Shorts are not appropriate for every venue, dressing appropriately for the occasion isn't so 80's but the sense of entitlement in your post is so very 2014. Definitely get the sundae for dessert (and ask for a sparkler!). Dude, dressing up means basically not wearing jeans or shorts, at this point in history. And we did, the cocktails were fantastic, but there was a live performer and the volume was over-the-top loud. West Orange, NJ. Highlawn Pavilion Highlawn Pavilion Claimed Review Save Share 407 reviews #1 of 60 Restaurants in West Orange $$$$ American Vegetarian Friendly Vegan Options Eagle Rock Reservation, West Orange, NJ 07052 +1 973-731-3463 Website Closed now : See all hours See all (160) Ratings and reviews 4.5 407 reviews #1 of 16 American in West Orange The manager was gracious and apologized. The chardonnay was $18/glass. Wine list skews Californian and Italian; prices typical for a restaurant. Absolute amazingview of NYC skyline.More, Been to the old Highlawn many, many times and enjoyed both the meals and the views and while it wasn't a gourmet delight the rest of the experience compensated. HOURS OF OPERATIONTuesday - Friday: 11:30AM - 3PM (Lunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner)Saturday 5PM- 10PM (Dinner & Bar)Sunday: 11:00AM -3PM (Brunch) | 3-5PM (Bar) | 5-10PM (Dinner). Managment deserves credit for bringing the whole extraordinary enterprise together. See Large Party Menus for Food Options. What's Up With The 1980's Dress Code At Highlawn P. Main course meals were average but the appetitizers and desserts were EVERYTHING! Ok, I'm calling Shenanigans on Rayo and Ilovepink - in this thread they are acting like they don't know each other but in a thread last year Rayo said he was the father of Ilovepink's son. Copyright 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.